This is the question asked by the star news to the dr.zakir naik a muslim spokesperson,a good speaker.He replied that even hindu dharmas are against the vandemataram they also says hindus shouldnt bow down to any body except god almighty.He quoted that a muslim never bow down to any body even to his mother and prophet also he bow downs only to the god(allah).He says we love our country but dnt bow down to it.My Answer:
In Hindu epic ramayana says "Janani jnmabhoomistya svargadapi gariyasi".We hindus belive in god we too bow down to him ONLY.That means not only the god inside the temple,we bow down to the god who is present in the form of our country(Baratha matha),we bow down to the god who is present in our great freedom fighters,we bow down to the god who is present in lakhs of soliders who are sacrificing their life,we bow down to the god who is present in every patriotic man from kashmir to kanyakumari,THATS Y HINDUS ARE SINGING VANDEMATARAM,NOT ONLY HINDUS EVERY ONE IN HINDUSTAN SHOULD SING VANDEMATARAM.
Finally in any hindu epic never says only hindus will go to paradise,only hindus get punished by god when they commited a crime,never wish only hindus should be happy.It says "Sarvejana Sukhinobhavanthu".All world should be happy this is the essence of Hinudism.
So my dear muslim frnds please its the matter of nation pride we should sing vandemataram.u can bow down to allah who is present in the form of this country.
Thank you
very nice and very impressive............
ReplyDeleteThe biggest error of analogy that you have made here is comparing god with country..........God is above nation,above the soldiers who sacrifice their life for us,above our real mother who gave us birth.....the postion of god is really very differnt....confusing concept of god with country,soldiers, or mother is really wrong.....hence i request all the hindu brother and sisters to abandon this vande matram song...which confuses different concepts.....may be songs like sare jahan sae acca ...should be given priority...because this is very meaningfull and logicaly right with concept of country......thank you all..
ReplyDeleteSeems the 'concept' of GOD is taken wrongly by the above person. Try to see GOD in everything and respect all...
ReplyDeletewhy dont we do so yes we cant compare god as nation but we can see god in our nation
ReplyDeleteyou people taken misconception here,wat i told was the nation is form of god the person who sacrifises his life is the form god we should respect god in all of them wats wrong in that.
gr8 saying by prahalada
endugaladanduledani sandehamu valadu
thandri chakri sarvopagathundu ndendu vetikina andande galdu vinte.
the god exists in all goods and exist against to all bads,they y cant we prayer to that god
the concept of god is that a thing which make good to you with respect to the society is a gods thing.that is you can treat that thing as shadow of god
ReplyDeleteVande Mataram is Hindues prayer , and that's good , India is Hindues country we are ready to worship anything we think is divine , we are not muslims who fear for the kayamat day in everything , there is no liberty in islam , and there hidden agenda is to convert whole world to islam , it is upto hindues to stop growth of islam in india
ReplyDeleteits whole india's prayer every indian should sing.who dnt want to sing has no right to live in this country.wats wrong in praising own country.we should do it.
ReplyDelete"liberal islam" or "tolerant islam" is oxymoron , if that is tolerant then that is not islam at all , but the explanation given by you is quite good , you can't expect those people to sing "vande mataram" who in 21st century don't allow their women to show faces in public.
ReplyDeletedear my brother,srusti is the creation of god for the peoples who want to teach good and lightning the peoples when they are in darkness.love world not only india.According to yadha yadha darmatcha......meaning when ever the evils and problems rises on srusti(world)(not only india) we are coming to slove in the shape of human beings.Please not make a limit to god to stick in india,he is viewing at all.
ReplyDeleteeven a nitya nanda is a god man,now is a sex man.please stop praising good people as a god,think the man is idle when ever evils will come in them and make them to go to hell.
so never pray a man as god even he is highly good.
hindus are the really innocents,they need god to pray,this weekness is using by some peoples to settle in their lifes.
if u r really interested to find the reallity of god,please read all the holy books,
if u r telling ram and krishna are gods,then y not moses(prophet who directly spoken with god almighty),abrahim (even fire has no impact when god make him guard on him),jesus(who burn with out father and talk immediately after birth),muhammed(show the right figure of god and sacrified a lot for human beings...etc are not gods.
please stop finding god in good peoples ,making temples on actresses,worshipping kabars,making god man to sex man by sending our sistem around them and allowing evil to sit on their heads.
we want peace,love the peoples who loves goodness and try to find god.
please dont comment any thing which u dont have full knowledge of that particular topic,
if knowledge is a godess(saraswati)then try to read all books to find the god,dont stick with one book,